What is not strategy

3478 reads

Managers use the word  strategy  very often. Yet there is considerable confusion about what it means and how to use it effectively. This is the first in a series of articles in which   Mr. Bhattacharya explores the misconceptions about Strategy

Strategy is necessary to make a firm competitive. This ignorance is dangerous in the fiercely competitive 

world of business today.  There is no other way to create wealth for shareholders and society. It is an absolute imperative for survival. It is, therefore, even harder to understand why managers responsible for the health of the corporation carry erroneous notions about it.



Most managers learn on the job. Their lack of understanding of strategy often reflects the leadership's discomfort with abstract concepts. It is a manifestation of their preference for the tangible and the specific. Quite often it is conditioned by their preoccupation with results and action. They lead to errors in what managers come to believe is strategy. There are five common misconceptions. They arise from mixing strategies with results, action, scale, operational efficiencies and risk mitigation. Let us see how each one clouds a manager's vision.


1. Confusing Strategy with Outcome.


A common error is confusing ends with means. It leads to strategies that read so: ‘our strategy will be to become the most admired company in our industry'; or, ‘to become a leader' in it. It may be stated as grow at a compounded annual growth rate of 15%; achieve revenue of 100 billion, increase market share or profitability to X%, and so on. These are not strategies. They are consequences. They are outcomes of competitiveness resulting from effective strategies.


A firm's turnover, market share or reputation grows when customers prefer to do business with them. Customers become predisposed to buy the company's products when they perceive greater or more unique value for the price they pay. To deliver greater value to customers the company must develop a game plan and execute is successfully.


The manner in which the firm gains the favour of customers is  business strategy   , also called  competitive strategy   . One company may do so by designing stylish products that are affordable, as Swatch does. Another might sell a functional detergent at a low price, like Nirma. Yet another may succeed hugely by combining superb quality at very attractive low prices. India is the best example of this strategy in providing offshore IT services to the world.


Each of them has used strategy to achieve desired ends - revenue, growth, profitability and reputation. In each case strategy has helped them give customers a compelling reason to buy their products or services. Means were crafted to reach where they wanted to go.  The goal is not strategy.


2. The Fallacy of Action.


Action is confused with strategy. This is perhaps the most common error. Managers tend to answer the question ‘How shall we achieve growth?' by offering a number of alternative actions. Let's enter new markets. Or, train sales engineers to sell better. Increase the number of calls sales people make. Introduce new products. Do something......anything!


Most industrial societies profess action orientation. The West drew it's inspiration from the Protestant work ethic. In other cultures, India for instance, business is greatly influenced if not shaped by western practices. Managers who are pragmatic, quick off the starting block & get things done are praised. Those who think are considered lazy. Action orientation is good for one's career. Recruiters actively look for such people. Hardly anyone hires ‘people who think'. Is it any wonder that strategy meetings lead to divergent ideas with nothing in common among them? The process is given the respectable name ‘brain storming'.


Strategists ask three questions: Where, How and What.   ‘Where' leads to the destination, the end they seek. Answers to ‘How' are the domain of strategy. They provide clues to the means by which the desired result may be achieved. ‘How' does not tell them what to do. It merely suggests the direction and the manner in which the goal may be accomplished.


‘What' prescribes activities that must be performed to achieve the stated goal by the means identified in strategy. Actions must flow from strategy if they are to remain consistent over time. Managers should be able to inventively use resources - cash, people, assets, etc. - to execute strategy. The activities that use these resources are the realm of tactics. They are not strategy.


It is true that our experience tells us which actions might succeed and which might not. They help us craft viable strategies. In that sense, strategy is the outcome of knowledge gained from past action. But it is the insight gained from activity, and not the activity itself, that helps us formulate strategy.


Tactics and strategy go hand in hand. Action is necessary to bring strategy to fruition. But without a game plan action, no matter how diligent, will not lead to the desired goal except by chance. Sun Tzu, the Chinese philosopher, put it perfectly, "Strategy without tactics is the slowest route to victory. Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat."


To be continued in the next issue..... 


vn_bhattacharya.jpg Mr. V.N. Bhattacharya is a management consultant on business and corporate strategy.  Feedback can be mailed to marketinggyan@businessgyan.com


Issue BG59 Feb06


johnsullivan's picture

The Candidates Are in Control: The New Age of Infinite Recruitment Marketing

SourceCon Atlanta delivered great insights into the changing nature of our industry. If you missed it, you should know that one of the underlying themes was “recruitment marketing is coming.” We are living in a time of unprecedented job advertising
johnsullivan's picture

The Top 18 Articles of 2018 – #2 Sourcing With Style – Creating Memorable Content

In the era of videos, emojis, and gifs, the written word is still a powerful way to share our thoughts, stories or how we learn. We have used stories for generations to pass on knowledge to others. It is still...
changethis's picture

Why You Don’t Need VC to Build a Billion Dollar Business

“Although the business press is filled with exploits of VC-funded ventures, the reality is that 94 percent of billion-dollar entrepreneurs took off without VC, and only about one in 10,000 entrepreneurs truly benefits from VC. Silicon Valley venture
harvardbusinessreview's picture

Why “Many-Model Thinkers” Make Better Decisions

Three ways to construct a powerful combination of perspectives.
businessstandard's picture

Goods transport cross borders

From: Buisness-standard By TNC RajagopalanRecommended by: business-standardLogistics service providers having registration as Authorised Economic Operators may now obtain a TIR-Carnet from the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and
sethgodin's picture

Go find a ladder

While it might be fun (or appear expedient, or brave, or heroic) to try to scale a cliff with no tools, it turns out that ladders are a more effective way to level up. When it’s time to drive a nail, a hammer is a lot more useful than a rock. Even
johnsullivan's picture

You Are Destroying Recruiting

This is the sense I get when reading so many articles or LinkedIn posts. Recruiters, especially new ones, are evil. They are lower than car salespeople, worse than the political campaign calls and just a wee bit better than the...
harvardbusinessreview's picture

Why CRM Projects Fail and How to Make Them More Successful

Use them to improve the sales process, not just evaluate it.
sethgodin's picture

Denying the heart

If you want to annoy someone with back pain, tell them it might be in their head. And if you want a medical practitioner to feel disrespected, you might trying bring up the placebo effect and how it’s often more effective than ‘real’ medicine.