Mr. Sharma has a problem!

531 reads

Competitive bidding is a fascinating subject; it is as much about business as about the workings of the human mind. The desire to achieve results prompts individuals to adopt strategies that reveal lessons from Game Theory. This issue relates to one such story.

Standard Metals, a large and reputed producer of steel, has bid to supply steel sections and other steel products to India Engineering & Construction Company (IECC).The steel will be used for construction of a bridge over a major river.

All things being equal 

IECC had floated a closed tender and invited twenty-three companies from India and abroad to submit prices for supply of steel. All bidders had been selected after a rigorous pre-qualification process.

The products of prospective vendors were approved after they had passed necessary tests.

According to tender rules, the lowest bidder would be the sole supplier. If more than one quotes the lowest price, each will be given equal share of the business.

Standard Metals and one other company – Sterling Steel Mills, a much smaller firm in size compared to  Standard – have quoted the same lowest price.

Fortunately, the winning price is reasonably profitable for both suppliers. In deference to their size and reputation, IECC have invited Standard first to finalise the order. Next they will meet representatives of Sterling to award the contract.

The Managing Director of Standard Metals has impressed upon Mr. Sharma, Vice President of Standard Metals, to wrest at least two-thirds of the business. He has been instructed to emphasise their size, reputation and history of good relationship with the Buyer.

In Mr. Sharma’s shoes 

Mr. Sharma has at least two choices: accept what is offered, that is 50% of the steel requirement, or decline anything less than two-thirds of the volume

If you were Mr. Sharma representing Standard Metals, what would you do? How would you handle the situation? What other cards, if any, would you play?

I would love to hear your comments. And respond to them in the next issue.


adamgrant's picture

The Two Traits of the Best Problem-Solving Teams

You want teams that are cognitively diverse and psychologically safe. A variety of thinking styles—coupled with the freedom to take risks without being punished—enables groups to generate, test, and implement creative ideas.Imagine you are a fly on
changethis's picture

Making ‘Agile’ Business as Usual

“There is more to Agility than putting lipstick on a pig. Organizations that attempt to migrate to Agile approaches need to take accountability for their 'inner pig.' Any sector can espouse Agile practices, such as SCRUMS, Sprints, and Stand-ups.
danielhpink's picture

Things: The secrets of high standards and happiness

1. WHAT TO READ: Can you teach high standards? Each year, Amazon founder Jeff Bezos — whose current personal net worth exceeds the GDP of nearly 150 nations — writes a letter to shareholders. Most corporate missives are snoozers, but Bezos’s is
mashable's picture

Google just slashed the price on its massive storage plans with Google One upgrade

Google's storage plans are getting cheaper. The company has launched a new storage plan called Google One, which offers significantly better deals than Google Drive storage plans. There's no need to switch, because all current Drive storage
changethis's picture

Start Imagining a Future of Human + Machine

“In the first wave of transformation, businesses standardized processes. Think Henry Ford and the assembly line, where steps in the overall process were broken down, measured, and optimized to achieve gains in efficiency. The second wave of
jackcanfield's picture

Try This Simple Night Meditation Called "The Evening Review"

Successful people maintain a positive focus in life no matter what is going on around them. They stay focused on their past successes rather than their past failures, and on the next action steps that will get them closer to the fulfillment of their
davecrenshaw's picture

How far would you go for a friend?

I recently witnessed an act of compassion and friendship so unexpected, it moved me to tears. And it happened in a very unlikely place: Pelican Bay super-maximum security prison. I support a program called Defy Ventures, an organization that works
johnsullivan's picture

Here We Go Again – LinkedIn Updates Its User Agreement

There are times in my life when I hate that I am right about something. Like the time I thought an employee was stealing from my store back in the day and two days later I caught them doing just...
changethis's picture

How Women Rise: Helping Women Change the Behaviors that Get in Their Way

“It’s not surprising that many of the behaviors that hold men and women back would be different. After all, women often have very different experiences at work. And experience shapes habits and responses.Familiar habits and responses may feel