Mr. Sharma has a problem!

695 reads

Competitive bidding is a fascinating subject; it is as much about business as about the workings of the human mind. The desire to achieve results prompts individuals to adopt strategies that reveal lessons from Game Theory. This issue relates to one such story.

Standard Metals, a large and reputed producer of steel, has bid to supply steel sections and other steel products to India Engineering & Construction Company (IECC).The steel will be used for construction of a bridge over a major river.

All things being equal 

IECC had floated a closed tender and invited twenty-three companies from India and abroad to submit prices for supply of steel. All bidders had been selected after a rigorous pre-qualification process.

The products of prospective vendors were approved after they had passed necessary tests.

According to tender rules, the lowest bidder would be the sole supplier. If more than one quotes the lowest price, each will be given equal share of the business.

Standard Metals and one other company – Sterling Steel Mills, a much smaller firm in size compared to  Standard – have quoted the same lowest price.

Fortunately, the winning price is reasonably profitable for both suppliers. In deference to their size and reputation, IECC have invited Standard first to finalise the order. Next they will meet representatives of Sterling to award the contract.

The Managing Director of Standard Metals has impressed upon Mr. Sharma, Vice President of Standard Metals, to wrest at least two-thirds of the business. He has been instructed to emphasise their size, reputation and history of good relationship with the Buyer.

In Mr. Sharma’s shoes 

Mr. Sharma has at least two choices: accept what is offered, that is 50% of the steel requirement, or decline anything less than two-thirds of the volume

If you were Mr. Sharma representing Standard Metals, what would you do? How would you handle the situation? What other cards, if any, would you play?

I would love to hear your comments. And respond to them in the next issue.


vnbhattacharya's picture

NARCOS and the game beyond the game

A critical aspect of strategic thinking is the ability to determine one's strategy in the game at hand by anticipating games in the future. It is especially important to foresee games that may be spawned by playing the game one is offered now.Such
sethgodin's picture

Big crew/little crew

Software projects work better with small teams. On the other hand, it makes sense to have multiple teams of workers if you're paving a patch of highly trafficked highway. Three reasons: Coordination Learning Ramp up time As we learned from... 
johnsullivan's picture

You’ll Soon Need a Digital Labor Specialist and a Workforce Shaper

Not all your employees will be replaced by robots, but it’s highly likely they’ll be working side-by-side with an automated device at some point in their careers. As intelligent automation becomes more common in the workplace, businesses are
mashable's picture

These extremely good Google Maps features that everyone definitely wanted are finally sort of available

For all of you who've been holding your breath this past month, it's finally time to exhale: On Tuesday, Google rolled out some of the hotly anticipated new Maps features the company announced in May. And by "rolled out," we mean "some people
johnsullivan's picture

Ready or Not Here Comes Generation Thumb

Talking about millennials in the workforce is so yesterday. Time now to start preparing for Gen Z, or, as Chad Norman calls them, Generation Thumb. This is the generation born after the turn of the century. They’ve never known a...
harvardbusinessreview's picture

When India Killed Off Cash Overnight

Bhaskar Chakravorti, the dean of global business at The Fletcher School at Tufts University, analyzes the economic impact of India’s unprecedented demonetization move in 2016. With no advance warning, India pulled the two largest banknotes from
sethgodin's picture

The jerk fallacy

There’s a common misperception, particularly in media, business and politics, that being a jerk is a necessary ingredient on the way to becoming and staying successful. But there’s no data to support this. Sure, some people succeed despite being
johnsullivan's picture

New to the Profession of Recruiting? Time to Get Comfortable With Being Uncomfortable

If you’re a seasoned and successful recruiter, chances are you have fine-tuned your skills over the years by going through a gauntlet of stressful, maddening, or even downright demoralizing work days. Most of my fellow recruiters and sourcing
cryptocurrency's picture

Jack Ma: Bitcoin Bubble is Real and Blockchain is the Future

 Jack Ma Bitcoin Bubble: Yet another well-known figure has come forward to express his thoughts on the cryptocurrency sector. The figure, who is Jack Ma, spoke specifically of Bitcoin (BTC) — and his thoughts weren’t exactly in favor of