Karnataka Election through the Lens of Game Theory

275 reads

Setting up the game

A week before the election, Sonia Gandhi anticipated that Congress might not win an outright victory. She requested Sitaram Yechury, the Communist Leader, to reach out to Deve Gowda, the JD(S) supremo. Yechury reminded Gowda how Congress support had been instrumental in he becoming the Prime Minister of India in 1996. He emphasised their mutual interest in stopping the BJP juggernaut in Karnataka.

Deve Gowda, the wily politician, laid down two conditions: his son Kumaraswamy would be the chief minister, and he would speak with Sonia, not Rahul Gandhi. He had been unhappy with Rahul for alleging that JD(S) had had a secret pact with BJP.

Recognising his potential advantage as kingmaker he leveraged his Added Value, as we say in Game Theory.

As vote counting progressed and a fractured mandate looked imminent, Sonia asked senior Congressman Ghulam Nabi Azad to meet Danish Ali,known as eyes and ears of Deve Gowda. She also asked Yechury to mollify Gowda. But to seal the pact she called the JD(S) patriarch personally on May 15, before final results were declared.

Pay me to play
Gowda exploited his Added Value once more. He asked for categorical assurance that the coalition would last the full five-year term. Sonia agreed. It was more important to keep BJP out of Karnataka and lay the foundations of a countrywide anti-BJP front for the 2019 parliamentary elections.

She played what is termed a strategic move in Game Theory. A strategic move, in this case a promise, limits the choices available to opponents and creates advantage for the player herself.

The Art of the Long View
What about BJP’s strategy? To appreciate it one must go back in time, long before the recent game was played out.

In 2006-07 JD(S) had first brought down the Congress chief minister and then its alliance with BJP. In 2008, BJP formed the government on its own, though with a thin majority. In 2013, Congress returned with an outright majority. BJP was always keen to bag Karnataka, now one of the last big non-BJP states.

Soon after assuming power at the Centre in May 2014, Modi appointed Vajubhai Bala as Governor of Karnataka. An old BJP loyalist, he served in Modi’s cabinet in Gujarat for fourteen years.

The referee is in your corner!
Fast forward to 2018. As events unfolded in May, the Governor asked Yediyurappa to be sworn in as Chief Minister on 17 May, ignoring the claims of the Congress-JD(S) alliance with 115 seats, a clear majority. More, he gave Yediyurappa an unprecedented 15 days to prove his strength on the floor of the House.Of course he acted perfectly legally. The Constitution accords discretion to the Governor.

Supreme Court intervened at the request of alliance partners and asked the Chief Minister to prove his majority on 19 May. Unable to muster requisite support, Yediyurappa quit ahead of the trust vote. Amit Shah’s strategy almost succeeded! Should we not credit Amit Shah’s (President of BJP and its chief strategist) foresight?

We can see that anticipation played the critical role in the strategies of each of the leaders. The long view of Amit Shah and Modi laid the ground for a possibility they had in all probability anticipated. Sonia Gandhi initiated dialogue with Deve Gowda a week before elections. She played a strategic move BEFORE election results were declared. Deve Gowda anticipated his kingmaker role and negotiated advantages for his party and son.

The next five years?
Aficionados of Game Theory can expect more action in future. Hectic parleys for ministerial berths are afoot even as I write this piece. In the months and years ahead there will be threats, promises, and innovative strategic moves by each of the three parties with the intent to sustain or destroy the coalition. No doubt with an eye on the 2019 parliamentary elections.

Uncertainty will be the essence of strategy in such fluid situations. And anticipation will remain the acme of strategic thinking.


adamgrant's picture

Most Personality Quizzes Are Junk Science. I Found One That Isn’t.

Most Personality Quizzes Are Junk Science. I Found One That Isn't."The MBTI is astrology for nerds." Say it with me again: personality types are a myth, traits are on a continuum, and the major dimensions include extravert-introvert, agreeable-
changethis's picture

What If Sellers Behaved as Leaders?

“It is time we start making a shift. Research shows you can make more sales by abandoning sales-y behaviors buyers resist and replacing them with leadership behaviors buyers desire. Sellers do extraordinary things when they stop pushing people to
adamgrant's picture

Is Curiosity As Good at Predicting Children’s Reading, Math Success as Self-Control? Study Says Yes

The joy of discovery matters as much as self-control, and matters even more for low-income children. We need to encourage kids to ask novel questions, not just give familiar answers.Ever since the landmark "marshmallow test" highlighted the
danielhpink's picture

PINKCAST: This is when to quit your job

Should you stay or should you go? After a few years at the same job, many of us begin asking that question.In the latest Pinkcast, former Wall Street analyst and venture capitalist Whitney Johnson offers the answer. You can watch the 136-second
changethis's picture

The Speed Trap: When Taking Your Time (Really) Matters

“Speed-for-speed’s-sake is about the most counterproductive* approach imaginable. (*I use counterproductive because it’s impolite to use “stupid”—which is what I really believe.)While we must indeed evolve and experiment rapidly, the process of
adamgrant's picture

How to Pick a Career (That Actually Fits You)

This is a post about something I’ve been wanting to write about forever: careers. Society tells us a lot of things about what we should want in a career and what the possibilities are—which is weird because I’m pretty sure society knows very little
danielhpink's picture

WHAT TO LISTEN TO: Some audiobooks are more equal than others

“Mr. Jones, of the Manor Farm, had locked the hen-houses for the night, but was too drunk to remember to shut the popholes.”So begins Animal Farm, George Orwell’s classic novella. I’ve read Animal Farm many times. But now, for the first time, I’m
changethis's picture

Beyond Business Results: Achieving Sustainable Success

“For most of my career, I focused on my next professional opportunity rather than on my present situation. I was committed to serving patients and to helping my company meet its goals; I was always looking down the line to what was coming next. What
danielhpink's picture

WHAT TO WATCH: The Happiest Guy in the World

Two decades ago, Mario Salcedo retired from his job and went on a cruise. He never came back. Mario wasn’t lost at sea. For more than 20 years, he's been a permanent resident on Royal Caribbean Cruises. You read that right. “Super Mario” has