Intuitive mind and business shipwrecks

375 reads

A number of my readers had responded to my March piece (Anticipation – A Special Skill of the Astute Strategist) by asking HOW. How can one develop the capacity and skill to foresee possible consequences of how the game is played? How does the astute strategist anticipate future games?

A good way to explore that question is to begin by asking why we are often unable to anticipate the future. The reason is our intuitive mind.

The intuitive mind

We use our intuition constantly. We assess a given situation, strategies available to us and to others, and from a quick impression of possible outcomes. Our intuitive mind has evolved to offer good enough solutions quickly. It works by rapidly constructing coherent stories from what we can immediately and easily observe. Its role is not to provide exhaustive solutions for that would defeat the primary purpose: speed.

The analytical mind 

It is the analytical mind that plays the role of the controller. Unfortunately, it is usually a lazy one and tends to endorse solutions offered by intuition.

Most of the times it works well. But every now and then we make errors of judgement, or are unable to foresee the future. That is when systematic errors – also called cognitive bias – occur.

McDonalds & United Airlines fiascos

The play between the intuitive and analytical minds explains why the McDonald’s Restaurant Manager evicted the homeless man without taking cognisance of what might happen in future. It would make clear why the United Airlines Gate Manager failed to foresee the firestorm that was unleashed by the forcible eviction a paying seated passenger. Seeing it in this light we can understand why Oskar Munoz, the CEO, was insensitive in his first response when he endorsed the action of the employee.

In each of these cases, the coherent stories of their intuition were based on company policies, and the need to follow established rules and practices. It seems more than likely that their analytical minds simply endorsed the intuitive solutions.

Stopping to ask oneself 

They could have acted differently if they had stopped to ask what consequences other than the intended ones might befall. This simple act of stopping to ask oneself engages the analytical mind. It creates an opportunity to see the game differently and improves the chance of discovering viable alternatives. In common parlance we call it a second thought.

Second thoughts are valuable because they can open the mind to reassessment of the situation and new possibilities. It does not follow that we always will find better alternatives. Cognitive bias is hard to overcome. The second thought may lead to reaffirmation of the first solution. But it has the potential to change things for the better. This is the power of contemplation, reflection.

We do not see cognitive bias in ourselves but are quick to observe it in others. Therein lies the second strategy: seek another opinion, especially contrarian advice. Surely, the Gate Manager of UA could have called a colleague, or his boss before precipitating the eviction? The Restaurant Manager could have too.

Willingness to see other viewpoints 

It may be argued that neither had the luxury of time. Really? The UA flight was already delayed. Would another few minutes have mattered compared to the fallout that followed? Could the Restaurant Manager have taken just a few more minutes over the decision? Could he have consulted one or two of his colleagues in the outlet? It is clear he could have. He would have received their unvarnished views only if he had built a reputation of listening to other points of view.

Building a coffee country 

VG Siddhartha inherited 350 acres of coffee plantations in Karnataka, India. He foresaw that scale was important for achieving low cost to ride out the yo-yo of international commodity prices. By 1993 he had increased the acreage to 3000. In 1995 he was India’s largest green bean exporter.

Wisely, he realised major coffee chain operators would enter India. He embarked on rapid and sustained expansion. Cafe Coffee Day has targeted new customers by opening Squares, Lounges to address different price-quality segments. They operate over 35,000 vending machines in offices and 900 kiosks.

Siddhartha’s strategy is a good example of distant vision, the ability to anticipate games beyond. Does it necessarily evidence reflection, consultation, and an open mind? No, But it would seem extremely unlikely that he figured it out all by himself instantly, would it not?


mashable's picture

Travel accessories to give you that first class feeling

Even if your vacation destination is amazing, getting there can be, well, another story. Between the Tetris game of packing your suitcase, the bustle of a full flight, and the dreaded middle seat, you might be exhausted even before you reach your
harvardbusinessreview's picture

Leaders Focus Too Much on Changing Policies, and Not Enough on Changing Minds

To achieve the outcomes you want, start by thinking about people and culture.
sethgodin's picture

If you need deadlines to do your best work

Make some up. There’s no shame in that. In fact, it’s a brilliant hack. Set up a method of reward or punishment with a third party. Money in escrow that goes to a cause you abhor. Public congratulations. Whatever the method, the point is the same:
sethgodin's picture

The shortcut crowd

There is no market. There are markets. And markets have segments. There are people who enjoy buying expensive wine. There are people who will save up their money to have a big wedding. There are people who pay to have a personal trainer… And within
johnsullivan's picture

A Look at What’s Ahead For Talent Management In the Middle East

Note: Hessa Al Ghurair, CHRO and head of corporate social responsibility at Commercial Bank International P.S.C., writes on the state of human resources in the Middle East. In this Q&A, she discusses the talent management issues facing
businessstandard's picture

In media innovation is outsourced, need more data analytics: Punit Misra

 You have spent about 20 years with Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) before moving to Zee. From consumer goods to media, what is the first thing that hits you?One, there are significant levels of consumer engagement. You use a shampoo or soap
johnsullivan's picture

5 Strategies For Getting Your Employees Excited and Smart About Open Enrollment

Communicating employee benefits is a year-round job –– making sure employees remember key dates, know how to make changes when they have a life event such as getting married, submit claims on time and so much more. But open enrollment...
businessstandard's picture

AI revolution and jobs in India

 We are all in a tizzy about what new-age “artificial intelligence” (AI) systems can do. Does this harm India's hope of large-scale labour-intensive production? The picture is more optimistic than meets the eye. The AI revolution is mere
johnsullivan's picture

3 Questions to Evaluate a Candidate’s Emotional Intelligence

When looking to fill an open position, a lot of factors go into the screening process for the perfect candidate. You want someone who has relevant experience; an acceptable number of years in the field; a solid work history; and,...