Is doing nothing a strategy?

319 reads

Sometime in 2012, a small company in Tamil Nadu (India) developed manure containing natural plant growth hormones, from seaweed. The gel had to be diluted with appropriate quantity of water before being applied to the soil. Quite quickly the company established a niche with a volume of approximately 10 MT per month.

Lure of profits 

Soon, two new players sensing an opportunity entered the same market. They introduced slightly inferior but cheaper products. Suddenly threatened, the first player mulled over several choices before the company, as below:

• Reduce prices and match the competition.

• Hire more sales people and appoint dealers in new regions.

• Increase dealer margin, advertise and run promotions.

• Reposition the product and charge a premium.

• Sue competitors on grounds of IPR infringement.

• Sit tight, do nothing, and hope for the best.

After much deliberation, the company decided to do nothing. It merely asked sales people to emphasise to dealers the superior quality and performance of their product. Surprisingly, sales quadrupled within a year.

The inertia paradox 

Pleasant surprise? Was the loss of market share to new entrants, who were growing themselves, worth it? It is clear the incumbent could not have grown the market on its own and sell four times more per month as quickly as it did. Considering it did nothing the outcome was certainly a pleasant one. But what explains this paradox?

Competition expands markets 

Entry of competition expanded the market. Suddenly there were three players promoting a relatively new concept and product category. They expanded the distribution network, and encouraged farmers to try the product. The market was evolving faster than when there was a single producer. And it was segmenting on the back of price and performance. The pioneer could not have achieved any of it alone.

Strategy lessons 

There are several lessons here for strategists.

First, competition is valuable. They help expand markets and catalyse growth. We should be able to discern when they help and when they do not.

Second, competition helps markets evolve and segment more quickly than in the hands of a monopoly operator. It offers incumbents the opportunity to fine tune offerings and position themselves.

Three, doing nothing can also be a good strategy.

Welcome competition 

Finally, bringing in players can be good for the health of a business especially in a nascent market. In this case it happened serendipitously. But astute strategists can proactively instigate the entry of new players – competitors, suppliers, and customers – for long-term gains.


mashable's picture

Travel accessories to give you that first class feeling

Even if your vacation destination is amazing, getting there can be, well, another story. Between the Tetris game of packing your suitcase, the bustle of a full flight, and the dreaded middle seat, you might be exhausted even before you reach your
harvardbusinessreview's picture

Leaders Focus Too Much on Changing Policies, and Not Enough on Changing Minds

To achieve the outcomes you want, start by thinking about people and culture.
sethgodin's picture

If you need deadlines to do your best work

Make some up. There’s no shame in that. In fact, it’s a brilliant hack. Set up a method of reward or punishment with a third party. Money in escrow that goes to a cause you abhor. Public congratulations. Whatever the method, the point is the same:
sethgodin's picture

The shortcut crowd

There is no market. There are markets. And markets have segments. There are people who enjoy buying expensive wine. There are people who will save up their money to have a big wedding. There are people who pay to have a personal trainer… And within
johnsullivan's picture

A Look at What’s Ahead For Talent Management In the Middle East

Note: Hessa Al Ghurair, CHRO and head of corporate social responsibility at Commercial Bank International P.S.C., writes on the state of human resources in the Middle East. In this Q&A, she discusses the talent management issues facing
businessstandard's picture

In media innovation is outsourced, need more data analytics: Punit Misra

 You have spent about 20 years with Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) before moving to Zee. From consumer goods to media, what is the first thing that hits you?One, there are significant levels of consumer engagement. You use a shampoo or soap
johnsullivan's picture

5 Strategies For Getting Your Employees Excited and Smart About Open Enrollment

Communicating employee benefits is a year-round job –– making sure employees remember key dates, know how to make changes when they have a life event such as getting married, submit claims on time and so much more. But open enrollment...
businessstandard's picture

AI revolution and jobs in India

 We are all in a tizzy about what new-age “artificial intelligence” (AI) systems can do. Does this harm India's hope of large-scale labour-intensive production? The picture is more optimistic than meets the eye. The AI revolution is mere
johnsullivan's picture

3 Questions to Evaluate a Candidate’s Emotional Intelligence

When looking to fill an open position, a lot of factors go into the screening process for the perfect candidate. You want someone who has relevant experience; an acceptable number of years in the field; a solid work history; and,...